As far as I see it, there were a few flaws in SA:2...

1. You had to use Tails/Robotnik and Knuckles/Rouge, and man were they slow.
2. You couldn't perform tons of dodges.
3. Whenever you attacked or jumped, you slowed down.
4. It took you ages to speed up.
5. Some of the boss fights were just too slow.

So, I think...

1. You should use Tails/Rouge for fast flying missions, Knuckles/Someone else (maybe Robotnik in a fast, powerful machine) for fast missions where you take things out.
2. You should be able to dodge using the X button (for GC) or something...
3. Attacking and jumping shouldn't slow you down.
4. You should be able to speed up faster.
5. Make the boss fights a lot faster. Say you're running down a massive motorway or something, with Shadow or Metal Sonic running along side you, you and them trying to body-slam each other or something. It would keep the game's fast pace.

It would also be cool to slow down time sometimes as well... say you had a small bar allowing you to do that, so you could react to people. Like if you were fighting Shadow, you could slow time down, stop him kicking you (you're the same speed, but it's easier to react and you get new combos), grab his leg, swing him around, throw him then run like hell after him. You could then go back to normal speed and charge after him very quickly.

Any more ideas?

Hmm... Well, for a story, and of course, like every game, it has to be robotnik with the damn chaos emeralds. But, anyway, you know how their stuck in that other world, and not THEIR world? Well, it should be like, robotnik is building a machine that uses all the chaos emeralds to teleport them back to their world, and he plans to leave sonic and the gang behind. So, there like, well...obviously trying to get through the portal for themselves too, but a whole bunch of crazy stuff happens. i dont know. Anyway, they should also have the ability for everyone to be able to go super/hyper. Or, atleast have a scene/battle at the end like they always do, but involving everyone who can go super. Btw, do you think rouge could go super?

Doesn't suit her that much, nor Eggman or Omega. It seems that only Sonic, Shadow, Knuckles and Tails can go Super... maybe they could introduce some more characters? Though that could make it too complex...

Yeah...your right. Although I really would like to see some of the other characters go super, instead of just sonic/shadow every time. Maybe Sonic and Knuckles could have a big part in the game. Ehh...Maybe Sonic and Shadow? Maybe like....a sequel to SA1?
I don't know...

or maybe eggman can go super and use his fatness to conquer the world..lol

that'd look overly stupid.... :lol:

very much so, but i'm sure it would be a great laugh. But, how the hell would a human look when its super? Because...theres no hair to do stuff and stuff...

nah, Sonic would just automatically Die... I sware it...It would be mocked by millions and Sega would have a hard time starting new plattformers....

oh, that reminds me. how the hell did stupid freakin mecha sonic go super in sonic3 and knuckles? hes a robot! hes not a cyborg, meaning he's not organic. how the hell could a robot use...freakin...powers and stuff....

ur imagination... leave it at that... Sonic didn't have to be advanced in the SEGA GENISIS days.. there wasn't even a story.. it was merely " beat eggman.." so it didn't matter as much....

yeah...i guess. Also, in the genesis games, i never knew about the chaos emeralds and the master emerald. I never knew what was going on at all, and...then again, i was only like 5-10 years old. I knew about eggman, sonic, knuckles, and tails, and i think i sorta knew who amy was. Everything was so confusing. oh, btw, i'm just now learning about the super emeralds...what are they, and how do u get them in the genesis games?

!!!! The super emeralds are another set of emeralds which can only be scene in the Sonic 3 and Knuckles add on. Remember in hidden palace in sonic 3, the stand next to the master emerald? Those are Super Emeralds. If you get all 7 of them you become "hyper" mode. Its a colorful sonic with 1 image of him running behind him( yes it is ONE image. Pause the game and look.) With Knuckles he gets to go super and hyper. He doesnt glow colors and he has one image of him behind him. And if you glide fast towards a wall, when u hit the wall u will destroy the badnicks on it.
with tails its a hyperform "no super" when he has 4 slave birds around his head like hes craz and the do the work of killin people for him. They all get faster. But DONT USES HYPER TAILS IN SANDOPOLIS ACT 1!! You will NEVER kill the monster cuz they keep hitting him.

lollerz...i know what they look like. 2 words: debug mode

i just didnt know... in hidden zone palace level 3? hmm..ill check it out

"I will first take over KRISPY KREME DOUGHNUTS! MUAHAHAHAHAHA!"

nah... not really i mean come on how can he all the walking and running if he's just gonna sit in his dumb floating wheelchair, in which i like to call it. :B): :ok:

FYI: Unless you guys are making your own SA, there won't be a third one unless you count Sonic Heroes as SA3.