I usually kiss with my eyes closed, and the one time I kissed Mr. Nest with my eyes open, I was fortunate enough to find out that he looks normal when he is about to kiss me..
I have kissed guys that I wasn't into with my eyes open.. and it was awkward.. half of the time, I am looking from side to side, saying "omg, should I stay, or should I run" in my head as they are about to kiss me, and the other half of the time, I am trying not to laugh at the funny face coming at me.. in that instance, I just smile to keep from laughing hysterically, and I close my eyes..
Luckily for me, those guys were cocky, clueless, idiots, who thought that kissing them would be the greatest thing to ever happen to me.. so I just let them think that I was all the more excited to kiss them..